It began when one group of mostly juvenile lake-goers at Darlington County Park got into an argument that somehow involved another group.
Because Darlington is a county park, Bergen County Sheriff Anthony Cureton has officers stationed there during peak hours.
His officers responded to the dispute and summoned Mahwah police.
At some point, an unidentified sheriff's officer fired a blast of pepper spray that injured several youngsters and officers.
"Looks like a Mahwah police officer got the worst of it," one responder said.
An army of sheriff's officers and police from surrounding towns converged at the public lake off Campgaw Road and Darlington Avenue. Several ambulance crews were summoned.
In the end, it was believed only one person needed hospital attention.
At least 10 others went through a decontamination unit that members of Ramsey Rescue set up at the park's entrance.
A couple of people were taken into custody and Mahwah police quickly had matters under control.
The lake was closed for the rest of the day.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Northern Highlands and receive free news updates.